Best Replacement Windows | 2024 Review of Brands And Types

Seeking the top window replacements in 2024 to enhance your home? Our experts have evaluated manufacturers nationwide and scrutinized over 200 window styles, compiling this freshly updated guide (along with costs) to assist you in selecting the ideal window for your residence.

Best Replacement Windows of 2024 - Top Brand Logos

How We Determined Which Windows Were Best

When conducting reviews of various replacement window companies and window types, our approach is thorough and multifaceted, ensuring we provide comprehensive and reliable recommendations.

  1. Company Evaluation: We start by assessing the reputation and history of each window manufacturer. This includes examining their years in business, customer reviews, industry awards, and any unique selling propositions they offer. We also consider their customer service quality and warranty terms.
  2. Product Analysis: For each window type, we delve into a detailed examination of the product’s features. This includes the materials used (like vinyl, wood, or aluminum), energy efficiency ratings (such as U-factor and Solar Heat Gain Coefficient), design options, durability, and maintenance requirements.
  3. Performance Testing: We conduct or refer to independent tests that measure how well windows withstand various conditions, such as extreme temperatures, humidity, wind, and rain. This helps us understand their longevity and performance over time.
  4. Installation Process: The ease and quality of installation are crucial. We look at the support the companies provide during installation, including instructional materials and customer support.
  5. Cost-Effectiveness: We analyze the cost of the windows in relation to their features and durability. This includes initial purchase price, potential energy savings, and maintenance costs over the lifespan of the window.
  6. Customer Feedback: We gather and analyze customer reviews and ratings, paying attention to common praises or complaints. This real-world feedback is vital in understanding the product’s performance and customer satisfaction.
  7. Innovation and Trends: We keep an eye on the latest trends and technological advancements in the window industry, evaluating how these innovations might benefit consumers.
  8. Environmental Impact: We consider the environmental sustainability of the windows, including the materials used, energy efficiency, and the manufacturer’s environmental policies.

Using this comprehensive methodology, we select the best windows based on a balance of quality, performance, cost, and customer satisfaction. Our goal is to provide a well-rounded perspective that helps homeowners make informed decisions for their window replacement needs. Here are our findings:

#1 Andersen Windows & Doors

Andersen windows logoHeadquarters: Bayport, MN
CEO: Jay Lund (Apr 1, 2011–)
Founder: Hans Andersen
Founded: July 25, 1903, Hudson, WI
Subsidiaries:Renewal by Andersen Corporation
5-star rating
Andersen Windows excel in quality and durability, offering a wide range of styles and materials. Their energy-efficient designs lead to significant cost savings, while their excellent customer service and robust warranties add peace of mind. Ideal for homeowners seeking long-term value and aesthetic versatility in their window choice.

Best Replacement Windows by Andersen Windows –  2024 Review

Andersen Windows E-Series

Andersen Windows E-Series combines style and functionality with a focus on custom-made, energy-efficient designs. These windows offer a broad selection of colors, woods, and hardware, catering to diverse architectural styles. Durable and low-maintenance, they are an excellent choice for both modern and traditional homes, albeit at a premium price.

Andersen E Series Double HungAndersen E Series Bay Window Andersen E Series Gliding Window


  1. Customization Options: Andersen Windows E-Series offers extensive customization, allowing customers to choose from a variety of colors, woods, and hardware styles to match their architectural preferences.
  2. Energy Efficiency: These windows are designed to be energy-efficient, potentially reducing heating and cooling costs while maintaining a comfortable indoor environment.


  1. Cost: The E-Series tends to be more expensive compared to standard windows, which could be a significant factor for budget-conscious homeowners.
  2. Maintenance Requirements: While they are durable, the wood components in the E-Series may require more maintenance over time compared to other materials like vinyl or fiberglass.

Average Cost of Andersen Windows:$400-$2500

Average Cost of Andersen E-Series Window: $1350-$3300


#2 Pella Windows


Headquarters: Pella, IA

CEO: W. Timothy Yaggi (May 9, 2016–)
Founded: 1925, Des Moines, IA
Number of employees: 7,000 (2019)
Founders: Peter Kuyper, Lucille Kuyper
Subsidiaries:Pease Industries Inc, Bonelli Enterprises
5-star rating
Pella windows are renowned for their quality craftsmanship and wide range of styles. For the price, they offer excellent energy efficiency, enhancing home comfort while reducing utility bills. With options like wood, fiberglass, and vinyl, Pella caters to various aesthetic preferences. However, they can be on the pricier side compared to other brands.

Best Replacement Windows by Pella –  2024 Review

Pella Windows  250 Series

The Pella 250 Series windows blend durability and energy efficiency, making them a solid choice for homeowners. These vinyl windows offer triple-pane glass for improved insulation and noise reduction. They are low-maintenance and provide good value for money. However, design options are limited compared to higher-end models.

Pella Window 250 Series - Single Hung  Pella Window 250 Series - double hung Pella Window 250 Series - awning


  1. Energy Efficiency: The Pella 250 Series features triple-pane glass, providing excellent insulation. This design helps in reducing energy costs by maintaining a consistent indoor temperature.
  2. Durability: These windows are known for their sturdy construction, offering longevity and resistance to wear and tear.


  1. Limited Customization: Compared to higher-end models, the 250 Series offers fewer design and color options, limiting customization possibilities.
  2. Cost: While offering good value, the initial investment for these windows can be higher than some other vinyl window options.

Average Cost of Pella Replacement Windows:$300-$1500

Average Cost of Pella 250 Series Average: $425-$1280


#3 Preservation Windows

Preservation Windows Logo NewHeadquarters: United Kingdom
CEO: Anthony Cadieux
Founded: 1948
Number of employees: 2,000+
Products: Windows, Siding, Doors
5-star rating
Preservation windows stand out for their superior craftsmanship and innovative technology. Known for exceptional energy efficiency, they help reduce heating and cooling costs. The windows feature durable materials, ensuring longevity and minimal maintenance. Aesthetically, they offer a wide range of styles and customization options, fitting various home designs. However, their premium quality comes with a higher price tag, and the extensive options might be overwhelming for some homeowners seeking simpler solutions.

Best Windows by Preservation –  2024 Review

Preservation Vinyl Windows

Preservation vinyl windows excel in combining energy efficiency with durability. Their multi-pane glass and quality insulation significantly reduce energy costs. The design offers a sleek, modern look with minimal maintenance needs. While they provide excellent long-term value, the initial cost is higher compared to some other vinyl window brands.

Preservation Vinyl Windows Double Hung  Preservation Vinyl Casement Windows  Preservation Vinyl Bay/Bow Windows


  1. Energy Efficiency: Preservation Vinyl Windows are designed with advanced features like multi-pane glass and superior insulation, which significantly enhance energy efficiency, leading to potential savings on heating and cooling costs.
  2. Low Maintenance: These windows are known for their durability and resistance to common issues like warping and fading, requiring minimal upkeep.


  1. Cost: They tend to be more expensive than many other vinyl window options, making them a higher upfront investment.
  2. Design Specificity: While they offer a range of styles, the design options might not match every architectural style, potentially limiting their suitability for certain types of homes.

Average Cost of Preservation Windows:$600-$2100

Average Cost Preservation Vinyl Windows:$550-$1900


#4 Milgard Windows & Doors

MILGARD windows logoHeadquarters: Tacoma, WA
Founded: 1962
CEO: Vishal Singh
Parent organization: MI Windows and Doors
Subsidiary:Class Fund, LLC
5-star rating
Milgard windows are highly regarded for their quality construction and broad selection of materials, including vinyl, aluminum, and fiberglass. These windows excel in energy efficiency, with options like double-glazing and low-E coatings, making them a practical choice for various climates. Milgard also offers an extensive warranty, ensuring customer satisfaction. However, pricing can be a bit steep, and the availability of certain styles or features may vary depending on the region.

Best Replacement Windows by Milgard –  2024 Review

Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series Replacement Windows

The Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series Windows offer a blend of affordability and quality, appealing to budget-conscious homeowners. These vinyl windows provide good energy efficiency and durability. The design is basic yet functional, fitting well in a variety of home styles. However, customization options are limited compared to higher-end series.

Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series Single Hung Windows Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series Casement Windows  Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series Sliding Door Windows


  1. Affordability: The Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series is priced competitively, making it an attractive option for homeowners seeking quality windows on a budget.
  2. Energy Efficiency: These windows provide good energy efficiency with features like weather-resistant frames and efficient glazing, helping to reduce heating and cooling costs.


  1. Limited Customization: The series offers fewer options in terms of styles and finishes compared to higher-end models, limiting personalization choices.
  2. Basic Design: While functional, the design of the V450 HomeMaker Series is more basic and may not match the aesthetic needs of all homeowners or architectural styles.

Average Cost of Milgard Windows:$800-$1700

Average Cost Milgard V450 HomeMaker Series Replacement Windows:$900-$1700


#5 Thompson Creek Window Company

Thompson Creek LogoHeadquarters: Upper Marlboro, MD
Founded: 1980
CEO: Rick Wuest
5-star rating
Thompson Creek Window Company excels in providing high-quality, custom-made windows that enhance both the aesthetics and energy efficiency of homes. Their dedication to customer service is evident, offering personalized consultations and professional installation. While pricing might be higher than some competitors, the value is justified by the durability and performance of their products. The company’s commitment to using locally sourced materials also appeals to eco-conscious consumers, making it a commendable choice for window replacement needs.

Best Windows by Thompson Creek –  2024 Review

Thompson Creek Sound Shield™ Windows

Thompson Creek’s Sound Shield™ Windows are a game-changer for noise reduction, offering an impressive sanctuary from external clamor. These windows are not only effective in dampening unwanted sounds but also maintain the company’s high standards of energy efficiency and durability. Ideal for urban areas or noisy neighborhoods, they provide a peaceful home environment, albeit at a premium price, reflecting their advanced technology and superior quality.

Thompson Creek Sound Shield™ Double Hung Windows Thompson Creek Sound Shield™ Picture Windows Thompson Creek Sound Shield™ Bay Windows


  1. Noise Reduction: These windows are highly effective in blocking external noise, making them ideal for homes in noisy areas or for individuals sensitive to sound.
  2. Energy Efficiency: Like other Thompson Creek products, these windows offer excellent energy efficiency, helping to reduce heating and cooling costs and minimizing environmental impact.


  1. Cost: The advanced technology and materials used in Sound Shield™ windows often come with a higher price tag compared to standard windows.
  2. Limited Style Options: While functional, there may be fewer design and style options available in the Sound Shield™ range, potentially limiting customization choices for homeowners.

Average Cost of Thompson Creek Windows:$375-$1500

Average Cost Thompson Creek Sound Shield™ Windows:$500-$1500


#6 Simonton Windows

Simonton Windows logoHeadquarters: Parkersburg, WV
Founded: 1946

Parent organizations:Ply Gem Industries, Inc., American Brands

5-star rating

Simonton Windows stands out for its durable and energy-efficient vinyl windows, offering a cost-effective solution for homeowners. Their range includes various styles and customizations, catering to different tastes. While highly functional, the vinyl material may not suit those preferring natural aesthetics. Overall, Simonton is a solid choice, balancing affordability with quality, and is particularly noted for its energy-saving features and low maintenance requirements.

Best Replacement Windows by Simonton –  2024 Review

Simonton Windows 5500 Collection

The Simonton Windows 5500 Collection combines elegance with practicality, offering a seamless blend of classic style and modern functionality. These windows boast superior energy efficiency, reducing heating and cooling costs. The collection’s customization options are a plus, allowing homeowners to tailor aesthetics to their liking. However, the higher price point and vinyl construction may not appeal to all. Overall, it’s a premium choice for both performance and design.

Simonton Windows 5500 Collection Double Hung  Simonton Windows 5500 Collection Bow Window Simonton Windows 5500 Collection Picture Window


  1. Energy Efficiency: The 5500 Collection is designed for optimal energy performance, helping to significantly reduce heating and cooling costs with its high-quality insulation properties.
  2. Customization Options: This collection offers a range of styles and finishes, allowing homeowners to tailor the windows to match their home’s aesthetic and functional needs.


  1. Cost: The premium features and customization options of the 5500 Collection come at a higher price point compared to basic window models.
  2. Vinyl Construction: While durable and low-maintenance, the vinyl material may not have the same natural aesthetic appeal as wood or other traditional materials, which might be a drawback for some customers.

Average Cost of Simonton Windows:$220-$500

Average Cost Simonton 5500 Collection Windows:$280-$450


#7 Alside Windows

Alside Windows logoHeadquarters: Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Founded: 1947

Accolades: Golden Hammer Award 2023, Energy Star Most Efficient

5-star rating

Alside Windows offers a diverse array of windows that cater to various budget and style preferences. Known for their durability and energy efficiency, these windows are a smart choice for homeowners looking to enhance their home’s insulation and curb appeal. The customization options are ample, allowing for personalization. However, some customers have noted variability in customer service experiences. Overall, Alside Windows presents a dependable, cost-effective solution for those seeking to upgrade their home windows.

Best Replacement Windows by Alside –  2024 Review

Alside Mezzo® Collection

Alside Mezzo® windows stand out for their sleek, modern design and exceptional energy efficiency. These vinyl windows are engineered for durability and low maintenance, making them a practical choice for various climates. The fusion-welded frame ensures robustness, while the aesthetic appeal complements different architectural styles. However, the vinyl construction might not suit all design preferences. Overall, Mezzo® windows offer a great blend of functionality, style, and energy savings.

Alside Mezzo® Vinyl Windows  Alside Mezzo® Picture Windows  Alside Mezzo® Replacement Windows


  1. Energy Efficiency: Alside Mezzo® windows are designed for high energy efficiency, helping to reduce heating and cooling costs with their advanced insulation properties.
  2. Modern Design: These windows feature a contemporary, sleek design that enhances the aesthetic appeal of a home, fitting well with various architectural styles.


  1. Vinyl Material: While durable and low-maintenance, the vinyl construction may not appeal to those who prefer the natural look and feel of wood or other traditional materials.
  2. Limited Customization: Compared to some other high-end window brands, Alside Mezzo® may offer fewer customization options in terms of colors, finishes, and unique design features.

Average Cost Alside Windows: $400-$700

Average Cost Alside Mezzo® Windows: $420-$550


#8 Atrium Windows

Atrium Windows logo

Parent organization: Ply Gem Holdings Inc.
Headquarters: Dallas, TX
Founded: 1946
Subsidiaries: Atrium Vinyl, Inc.,

5-star rating

Atrium Windows is a reputable brand in the window industry, known for its wide range of affordable yet quality window options. They specialize in vinyl windows, which are praised for their durability, low maintenance, and good insulation properties. Atrium’s windows are available in various styles, catering to different architectural needs. However, some customers might find the design options limited compared to premium brands. Overall, Atrium Windows is a solid choice for those seeking value and reliability.

Best Replacement Windows by Atrium –  2024 Review

Atrium Series 8900

The Atrium Series 8900 stands out for its exceptional blend of durability, energy efficiency, and aesthetic versatility. These premium vinyl windows offer enhanced insulation and are designed to withstand diverse weather conditions, making them a practical choice for various regions. With several customization options, they suit different architectural styles. However, the cost may be higher than basic models. Overall, the Series 8900 is an excellent investment for long-term home comfort.

Atrium Series 8900 Double Hung Window  Atrium Series 8900 Tilt Single HungWindow Atrium Series 8900 Casement Window


  1. High Durability: The Series 8900 windows are built to last, with sturdy construction that withstands harsh weather conditions, ensuring long-term performance and reliability.
  2. Energy Efficiency: These windows are designed for superior energy efficiency, offering excellent insulation that can help reduce heating and cooling costs significantly.


  1. Cost: The premium features of the Series 8900 come at a higher price point, making them more expensive than standard window options.
  2. Vinyl Material Limitations: While durable and low-maintenance, the vinyl construction may not suit those who prefer the natural aesthetic and feel of traditional materials like wood.

Average Cost Atrium Windows: $275-$600

Average Cost Atrium Series 8900 Windows: $400-$650


#9 Marvin Windows and Doors

Marvin Windows  logo

Headquarters: Kearney, NE
Founded: 1912

5-star rating

Marvin Windows excels in combining craftsmanship with innovation, offering a high-end range of customizable windows. Known for their exceptional quality, these windows feature advanced materials like wood and fiberglass, catering to both traditional and modern aesthetics. The energy efficiency of their products is commendable, contributing to significant energy savings. While the cost is on the higher side, it reflects the superior durability and performance of their windows, making Marvin a top choice for discerning homeowners.

Best Replacement Windows by Marvin Windows and Doors –  2024 Review

Marvin Elevate® Collection

The Marvin Elevate® Collection expertly balances functionality with style. These windows fuse strong, weather-resistant fiberglass exteriors with warm, aesthetically pleasing wood interiors. Known for their durability and energy efficiency, they suit a variety of architectural styles. While premium in pricing, the Elevate® Collection offers long-term value with its low maintenance and superior performance, making it a favored choice for those seeking quality and elegance in their homes.

Marvin Elevate® Collection Double Hung   Marvin Elevate® Collection Awning Window Marvin Elevate® Collection Bay Window


  1. Durability and Weather Resistance: The Elevate® Collection features a unique combination of fiberglass exteriors and wood interiors, providing exceptional strength, durability, and resistance to harsh weather conditions.
  2. Aesthetic Appeal: These windows offer the beauty of natural wood interiors, which can be tailored to fit various home styles, adding a touch of elegance and warmth to any space.


  1. Higher Cost: The advanced materials and craftsmanship of the Elevate® Collection place it at a higher price point compared to standard windows, potentially making it less accessible for budget-conscious consumers.
  2. Maintenance of Wood Interiors: While the fiberglass exterior is low-maintenance, the wood interior may require more upkeep over time to maintain its appearance and integrity, especially in climates with high humidity or extreme temperature changes.

Average Cost Marvin Windows: $275-$800

Average Cost Marvin Elevate® Collection: $450-$800


#10 Jeld-Wen Windows

Jeld-Wen Window  logo

Headquarters: Charlotte, NC
CEO: Gary S. Michel (Jun 18, 2018–)
Number of employees: 23,300 (2020)
Founded: 1960, Klamath Falls, OR
Parent organization: JELD-WEN Holding, Inc.
Subsidiaries: JELD-WEN A/S, JELD-WEN of Canada Ltd.

5-star rating

Jeld-Wen Windows is a well-regarded brand in the industry, offering a wide selection of window types and styles. These windows are known for their versatility, catering to both traditional and contemporary homes. They provide good energy efficiency and durability, particularly in their vinyl and wood window lines. Some customers, however, have reported inconsistencies in quality and customer service. Overall, Jeld-Wen offers a range of options to suit various preferences and budgets, striking a balance between cost and quality.

Best Replacement Windows by Jeld-Wen and Doors –  2024 Review

Jeld-Wen Auraline® Replacement Windows

Jeld-Wen’s Auraline® Replacement Windows blend modern innovation with sleek design, offering a refreshing update for any home. These windows stand out for their energy efficiency and robust construction. The clean, minimalist aesthetic complements contemporary architectural styles. While the pricing might be a consideration for some, the long-term benefits of durability and energy savings make Auraline® a worthwhile investment for those seeking quality and style in window replacements.

Jeld-Wen Auraline® Single Hung Windows  Jeld-Wen Auraline® Awning Windows Jeld-Wen Auraline® Patio Door


  1. Energy Efficiency: Auraline® windows are designed for superior energy performance, helping to reduce heating and cooling costs thanks to their advanced insulation properties.
  2. Modern Aesthetic: These windows feature a sleek, contemporary design that can enhance the visual appeal of a home, fitting well with modern architectural styles.


  1. Cost: The Auraline® series, with its advanced features and design, may come at a higher price point compared to more basic window options.
  2. Limited Style Variety: While aesthetically pleasing in modern contexts, the specific design of Auraline® windows may not align with traditional or eclectic home styles, limiting their versatility in some architectural setting

Average Cost Jeld-Wen Windows: $225-$850

Average Cost Jeld-Wen Auraline® Collection: $350-$750


Top 10 Replacement Windows of 2024 (Watch)

What to Look For When Buying Replacement Windows

When buying replacement windows for your home, several crucial factors should be considered to ensure you make a wise investment. Here are some key aspects to look for:

  1. Window Material: Choose the right material based on your needs and budget. Common options include vinyl, wood, aluminum, and fiberglass. Each material has its own benefits and drawbacks in terms of durability, maintenance, and energy efficiency.
  2. Energy Efficiency: Look for windows with high energy efficiency ratings, such as ENERGY STAR certification. Features like double or triple glazing, low-emissivity (Low-E) coatings, and gas fills (like argon or krypton) can help reduce energy bills and maintain comfortable indoor temperatures.
  3. Window Style: Consider the architectural style of your home and your aesthetic preferences. Options include single-hung, double-hung, casement, sliding, awning, bay, and bow windows, among others.
  4. Frame Type: Frames can impact both aesthetics and insulation. Decide between full-frame replacement (removing the entire existing window) or retrofit installation (fitting new windows into the existing frames).
  5. Glass Options: Think about factors like tinting, decorative patterns, and safety glass (e.g., tempered or laminated) based on your privacy and security needs.
  6. U-Factor and SHGC: Pay attention to the U-factor (insulation rating) and solar heat gain coefficient (SHGC) when comparing windows. Lower U-factors and appropriate SHGC values will help maintain a comfortable indoor environment.
  7. Warranty: Ensure the manufacturer provides a solid warranty that covers defects, workmanship, and performance. A reliable warranty can give you peace of mind regarding the longevity of your investment.
  8. Installation: Quality installation is as important as the windows themselves. Choose a reputable contractor with experience in window replacement to ensure a proper fit and insulation.
  9. Price and Budget: Consider your budget and compare prices from different manufacturers and suppliers. Remember that higher-quality, energy-efficient windows may have a higher upfront cost but can lead to long-term savings.
  10. Local Codes and Regulations: Be aware of local building codes and regulations that may dictate specific requirements for replacement windows, such as size, egress, and energy efficiency standards.

In conclusion, buying replacement windows is a significant decision that can affect your home’s comfort, energy efficiency, and aesthetics. Careful consideration of these factors will help you make an informed choice that suits your needs and enhances your home’s overall value.

How Much Do Replacement Windows Cost in 2024?

The cost of replacing home windows can vary significantly depending on various factors such as the number of windows, their size, materials, and the complexity of installation. On average, homeowners can expect to spend anywhere from $300 to $1,200 per window, including both materials and installation. For a standard 2,000-square-foot home with 10 windows, the total cost could range from $4,000 to $14,000.

Buy Smarter - Spend Less Branded

Investing in energy-efficient windows often comes with a higher upfront cost compared to traditional windows. However, these windows can yield substantial long-term savings. Energy-efficient windows are designed to minimize heat transfer, which means they can reduce heating and cooling costs by up to 25%. This translates to hundreds of dollars in annual energy savings for an average-sized home. Over the lifespan of the windows, which can be 20 years or more, these savings can amount to thousands of dollars.

Regarding the DIY vs. professional installation, while DIY projects can reduce labor costs, they come with risks. Incorrectly installed windows can lead to drafts, moisture issues, and even structural problems. Hiring a professional ensures proper installation, potentially increasing the energy savings and the longevity of the windows. The cost of professional installation typically adds 25-50% to the total project cost, but the peace of mind and the potential energy savings make it a worthwhile investment for many homeowners. Ultimately, the choice between DIY and professional installation should consider your skill level and willingness to take on the project’s challenges.


Leave a Reply